Milk Carton vs Candy Wrapper

It's the battle of the boxes. Here a side-by-side comparison of boxes made using the Milk Carton Die and the Candy Wrapper Die.
The left is the Milk Carton Die, the middle is the Candy Wrapper Die and the right is the Milk Carton Die with a ribbon closure. The Candy Wrapper box is slightly taller than the Milk Carton box.

But the Milk Carton box is larger in circumference.

Since I already have the Candy Wrapper die, I think I'll stick to making those boxes. Which box do you like better?